Hall of Fame

These are the stories that I keep coming back to. I’ll put links up eventually, that’s just a lot of work and these aren’t too hard to find. This is also very partial, hard to remember everything all at once. One thing that I discovered as putting this list together – stories that aren’t themes I typically enjoy play an outsized role. But perhaps their atypical settings are exactly why I the get hall of fame status – there’s no other options for me, so when I’m in that mood, they’re the ones I go to.

Literotica-Compatible

• A.C. Trip by Rich5Spot (MF)
  • An incredibly hot woman acting incredibly sexual augmented by the suspense of her husband not knowing if the things he’s hearing about her are true. The voyeurism is light, allowing you to focus on the woman’s sexual talents while giving just a tinge of extra drama to keep you reading.
• All About Donna by Tall_cool_one (Mf, Ff, MFf, F/D, M/D)
  • Donna works both her parents and eventually gets everyone what they’ve been needing.
• Discovering My Little Sister Chapter 5 by Doublethink34
  • The only one of my stories that I really think is that good. I’ve developed some slight criticism of this as time has passed, but the way everything comes together in this chapter is just spot-on. Nothing, for me, tops the scene where Joy and Linda follow Polly into the bedroom from the hot tub.
• Dr. Mabuse SOI: Scott, Brenda, Beth, & Andy by dr mabuse SOI (MFff, ff, F/D, M/D, S/S)
  • A fantastic story of a man and his wife falling into bed with their two daughters. Like most dr mabuse SOI stories, the follow-up is poor, but the seduction is incredible and the initial scene is amazing. Despite the weak follow-up, seeds are sown for the reader’s imagination to continue the various plotlines established, which makes this a story that keeps giving years after the first read.
• How Mom Made Him State Champ by klxro (M/S)
  • A slow burn that branches out very widely but keeps you waiting.
• Kristen Finally Fucks Daddy by NonStopFunGuy (Mf, orgy, F/D)
  • A very, very slow burn, but with so many subplots that there are also many, many releases. I’ll probably never decide if the final chapter is a letdown or exactly what was necessary after so many opportunities to end the story were bypassed in the name of fantastic writing.
• Naughty Nicole by epiphany65 (Cm/Cf, B/S)
  • Cousins are a bit tame around here, but by far the best cousin story you’ll read. And as time goes on, things just get more fun.
• Our Porn Princess by nasty_dan (MF, MFf, F/D)
  • Each parent’s fantasy crosses a line, then they roleplay those fantasies, and then, finally, the fantasy comes true.
• Rocking Robyn by aphrodyte (B/S)
  • Relatively slow buildup in a short story. Missing some development for sure, but brother and sister falling together this way is just spot-on erotica.
• Sara’s Seductive Charms by racerex (MF, feet, cheating)
  • The first voyeuristic story that I ever enjoyed, and there are still very few. But the excitement, the dramatic irony, and the way Sara can shift from seductive to submissive to dominant as her partner needs are incredibly hot.
  • Several other of racerex’s stories should be on here, but I have to re-read them to figure out which ones as the others have similar themes and not all of them have satisfactory conclusions. All his stories are worth a read, they just aren’t all hall of fame-worthy.
• Silhouette Scenes by jaybee (F/D)
  • This one goes fast, and really, I can’t explain why I go back to this one, I just know that I do. I think the speed may be part of the reason. One minute the story is plodding along, no clear direction, and the next, everything is happening.
• Slippery Susie by RedHairedandFriendly, additional chapters commissioned by and posted by Marshal60 on xxnx.com forums (MMF, cheating, solo)
  • As a general rule, stories I like have one dick max. But something about Susie’s raw passion for sex allowed me to read past those descriptions that I did not enjoy. Somehow the story is all about Susie, her feelings and her insatiable desire to cum.
  • Past chapter 4 or 5, the stories get hard to find and they aren’t worth it. The later chapters a not Literotica-compatible, and more importantly they aren’t good. They create a backstory that completely contradicts the Susie character’s emotions and thoughts from the original chapters.
• Thrice by jaybee (Mfff, F/D)
  • The question when a man takes his wife and three daughters to a cabin isn’t what, but how. In this case, he needed a fairly intense catalyst. The biggest question is whether the story or the epilogue is better.

Not Compatible With Literotica

These stories would be rejected by Literotica in a heartbeat. If such themes offend you, do not continue. They are fantasy only, and should never be anything more than fantasy.

If you confuse fantasy and reality, or if you ever have a thought of making these fantasies reality, stop. Stop reading, don’t even read my stories, turn off your internet, get a therapist, and focus your energies elsewhere, ideally somewhere that puts good into the world without putting you close to where you could confuse fantasy and reality.

• Daughter’s Incestuous Therapy by mypenname3000 (mypenname3000.com) (Ff, MFF, M/D, F/D, M/S, B/S)
  • Full disclosure, I haven’t finished this one. This was the first story that I read by mypenname3000 and as good as the story was, I started getting lost from not having read the prequels. But it’s so good that every time I go back, I start from the beginning and completely enjoy. Which is part of why I haven’t finished.
• Doctor’s Incestuous Family by mypenname3000 (mypenname3000.com) (Fm, mf, M/S, B/S, M/D)
  • By far my favorite (that I’ve finished) from mypenname3000. Daughter’s Incestuous Therapy could definitely take away that title once I finish, but for now, this one is tops. If you’re like me and don’t care much for the brother-sister, skipping to chapter 3 only loses a bit of Dr. Wilson’s development that you’ll want. There is a Literotica version of this story, I’ve only read a bit of that, but the adjustments he had to make for Literotica make the characters a lot less realistic.
• Incestuous Harem by mypenname3000 (mypenname3000.com) (Fm, FFm, mf, mff, FFmfff+, orgy, Cm/Cf, M/S, M/D, B/S, Au/Ne, Au/Ni)
  • There’s not much more to say about this than the title, except that in the end, there’s one man and nine women, most of whom are close family. The story also brilliantly effects the ultimate modern life, where finances are easy to take care of and hot sex is easy to come by. My one criticism is that as the story goes on, relationships with the mother and aunt are de-emphasized and the sisters and cousins take on a greater role. My preference, of course, is the intergenerational stuff.
• My Girls by unknown1000u2 (wolfpub.org) (Mg,
  • This story is average to above average as a piece of erotica: there are some great scenes, some not my taste (non-consensual), and some that happen so quickly after so much non-erotic development that you’re barely hard (or not wet at all, if that’s how your anatomy works) by the time the scene ends. But as a story, there’s none better on this list. There’s hardly one better ever written. The erotic content will forever relegate this story to the dark corners of the internet, but you won’t want to stop reading. A few of the erotic scenes were uninteresting to me just because I was more interested in what was going to happen than in sex. You won’t regret all the time reading this story takes.
• Pam by seepam20 (nifty.org) (Fg, gg, Au/Ni, M/D)
  • This 17-chapter, incomplete lesbian story is absolutely incredible. The grammar is awful – the first grammatical error being at the fifth word and the second at the sixth word – but as you read, you find that the grammar serves to build the narrator’s character and put you deeper into her psyche. The frustration of Pam and Aunt Betty never seeming to be able to express what they need just keeps you glued, each step forward an incredible release and each step back a crushing blow. As Pam branches out, the drama only increases. I discovered this story just days after Chapter 17 dropped, and there hasn’t been another for 18 years. Talk about frustration.
• Right Up Her Allie by StarSapphire (nifty.org) (Fg, Fgg, FFgg, M/D)
  • A beautiful story of a woman succumbing to her love for her daughter’s friend.